A new Working Paper by Martin Edwards entitled The Institution of Firearms Dealing is available. Martin is an Associate Professor of Law at The University of Mississippi School of Law. The paper’s abstract reads:

Any time a gun moves through commerce, federal law requires that it be transferred from, to, or through a Federal Firearms Licensee (FFL). The entire supply chain in firearms exists atop or alongside this longstanding legal and economic institution, which this Article dubs “the FFL system.” Even so, gun rights advocates and gun control advocates alike largely take it for granted or ignore its underlying economic logic.

Gun rights advocates pragmatically view anything but marginal scaling back of federal firearms licensing regulation to be politically unpalatable, whether they view the system as generally good policy or as an impediment to lawful firearms ownership. They may miss the economic benefits that flow from the existence of the system, expanding access to firearms and accessories and, indirectly, support for gun rights. Gun control advocates focus only on building new restrictions on top of the current system to achieve public safety goals. They might not notice that the economic dynamics in the system lower enforcement costs and direct scarce enforcement resources to their most efficient use, thus serving those public safety goals.

This Article presents an institutional economics analysis of the FFL system. It shows how the FFL system incentivizes licensees to make firearms-specific investments, which become an economic asset. Understanding this economic asset reveals two important implications for firearms law scholars, policymakers, and regulators on both sides of the policy debate. For gun rights advocates, each licensee’s investment in his or her firearms business expands distribution of firearms and related products, reduces the cost of innovations in the field, and provides more access to firearms, accessories, and shooting sports to law-abiding consumers. This grows the market in firearms and firearm products, while also generating new communities of shooters that may be more supportive of gun rights more broadly.

Of interest to gun control advocates, the asset creates a bond that reinforces regulatory efforts. A dealer that makes extensive firearms-specific investments, and then violates the law, will lose those investments—the more the dealer has invested, the more the dealer loses by breaking the law. This incentive reinforces legal penalties without enforcers having to spend any enforcement resources. Similarly, regulators could identify risky dealers based their level of investment, a regulatory enforcement method that might assist regulators in allocating scarce enforcement resources.

 

WHAT TO READ NEXT

WHAT TO READ NEXT