The rational justification of gun ownership typically centers around philosophical, legal, or political arguments. A less-explored question is whether there exist any theological grounds to support gun ownership. For many, religious beliefs play a vital role in their decision-making as individuals. As such, it is worth exploring whether gun ownership aligns with religious doctrines.
In 2021, I published a paper in Evangelical Quarterly that attempted to answer this question from within the Christian tradition. The crux of my argument is that armed self-defense is endorsed by Jesus in Luke 22:36, and that gun ownership is simply a modern-day extension of Jesus’s injunction to “buy a sword.” Despite that self-defense interpretation not having been particularly novel—having been defended by biblical scholars for centuries—my article was (to my knowledge) the first scholarly paper to apply this passage to private gun ownership.
In the article, I argue that (1) the proper exegesis of Luke 22:36 supports an injunction to acquire weapons for self-defense, (2) the conceptual context of this injunction is still applicable today, (3) small arms are the contemporary equivalent of the sword in biblical times, and (4) private gun ownership can also be defended on independent philosophical grounds that enhance the biblical argument. Along the way, I addressed rival interpretations of Luke 22:36 and other objections that pertain to the alleged incompatibility of Christian love and resistance against attack.
My core thesis is that Jesus is endorsing armed self-defense when he instructs the disciples to sell their cloaks and acquire swords. In Luke 22, Jesus addresses his disciples during the Last Supper, shortly before his arrest, trial, and eventual crucifixion. He reminds them of how their earthly needs were providentially met when he sent them out to do ministry work (Luke 9:1–6). However, Jesus warns that he will soon no longer be with them, and that in his absence they cannot expect the same level of protection and provision they received when he was physically present. Thus, Jesus instructs the disciples to take appropriate measures to be ready to provide for themselves. Purchasing a sword is explicitly mentioned as one of these measures.
Jesus was acutely aware that the world contains danger, so he instructed his disciples to make necessary preparations for their earthly needs to be met. In the same spirit, the contemporary equivalent of a sword is a firearm. Much like swords, firearms make it possible to put up an effective fight by enhancing one’s ability to defend oneself and others. Thus, the same reasoning behind Jesus’s instruction to buy swords can be extended to gun ownership and gun carrying.
About one year later, theologian Chris Barrigar published a reply in which he disputed the theological and philosophical arguments found in my original paper. Barrigar’s replies were not convincing, having grave deficiencies in multiple areas. The most recent issue of Evangelical Quarterly contains my critique of Barrigar’s response. In my response article, I argue that Barrigar’s critique fails because it (1) incorrectly situates my arguments in the wrong conceptual context, (2) inadequately engages with my exegetical arguments, (3) misunderstands and thus fails to engage with the relevant philosophical arguments, (4) ignores my existing work addressing some of his objections, and (5) misinterprets the relevant empirical evidence.
In short, Barrigar’s reply contains several errors across different categories. He does not engage with the substance of my exegetical arguments and ignores important nuances when it comes to understanding the empirical data. Most substantially, Barrigar attacks a strawman by attributing to me a theory of rights that I do not defend (and have even critiqued in other articles). Many of Barrigar’s critiques easily fail because they presuppose a conceptual framework that I do not utilize.
Barrigar was invited by the journal to write a response as the last word. His reply appears in the same issue, in which he argues for a shalom-based starting point over my natural law account of rights. My reply is forthcoming and will be posted here on the Firearms Research Center’s website.